Skip to Content

The Guide to Getting Your Picky Toddler to Eat a Variety of Foods

My child went from a happy baby willing to try anything to slowly but surely only being willing to eat dairy, breads, and packets. Originally, I thought it was a phase that would fix itself but that didn’t seem to be the case. So, I started to work at finding the best ways to approach this. How to encourage toddler to try new foods. Overcome a toddler who is a picky eater. Make child eat healthier. #parenting

Two hit us hard. The moment my child turned two, I knew we were in for it. Not only did her temper tantrums get a whole lot worse, but she quit eating variety.

She went from being a happy baby willing to try anything to slowly but surely only being willing to eat dairy, breads, and packets.

Originally, I thought it was a phase that would fix itself but that didn’t seem to be the case. So, I started to work at finding the best ways to approach this. I wanted a way that wouldn’t backfire on me years later. I wanted her to enjoy trying new foods and eating. I didn’t want to force feed my child every single dinner.

And it turns out, there was a lot I could do and after implementing this, I had a toddler asking to try new foods within a week.

Stop asking “do you like it?”

By asking this question, you are just asking for a no. Also, they probably don’t like it. It takes at least 21 times of trying a food before you like it. Additionally, those baby packets, while they have vegetables in them, all taste like fruit so they don’t really count.

In a few points below, I will tell you what you should be asking, but for now rule number one is do not ask if they like it or any variation.

Stop asking “what do you want to eat?”

I used to always ask this. I got told that if you present kids with some options then they will eat what they need nutritionally. Kids are very good at listening to their bodies.

The big catch here is to present the options. By asking such an open-ended question, you are first setting yourself up for failure as in they get to pick what they eat. If they get to pick, then why would they want to suddenly want to eat what you decide. Second, they don’t even know what is available or what can be made for them.

While it is best to follow this rule for all meals, I think it’s most important for dinner. Everyone should always eat the same foods. For instance, if you have a stir fry, you can give your toddler a small serving of diced broccoli, a serving of rice, etc. Everyone is eating the same dinner but in different forms.

Your big goal here is that they see everyone doing the same thing. It becomes the norm for them.

Always include a “safe” food and a “new” food to the plate.

Whenever you give your little one a snack or a meal, try to always include a food you are trying to get them to eat. Always include a food item they know and love. What you are trying to do here is not make it so foreign that there is something on their plate that they don’t know.

Additionally, you might even find that your child will try the new food item on their plate by themselves. But if that doesn’t happen don’t worry, these next few points will show you how to get them to try it.

The “What does it take like?” Game

Here is what I was missing. This simple, yet so smart idea completely changed my toddler to thinking that trying new foods was the most awesome thing to do. She now asks to play it.

So, what is it exactly? The problem with telling your kid to try foods is that it turns into a battle. Additionally, the goal is for them to like it and as I said above, they probably don’t like it. Now, we have a new goal. The goal is to decide what it tastes like?

Introduce the game at dinner time. Let’s say the new food is to try a piece of cucumber. Give everyone (parents included) a bite sized piece. So, peel it and dice it. By making it the size of one toddler bite, you increase your chances of them actually eating it (and not spitting it back out).

Now, before starting to eat dinner, say now we get to play the taste game. Have you and your other half be very excited. Explain that everyone is going to try the same new food (we are all going to try cucumber and decide what it tastes like). Have a parent go first. You just eat the food make funny faces and describe the taste (cold, kind of crunchy, sour, sweet, etc.). You can even make up tastes (it takes kind of purpley). The goal is to make this fun and silly.

Then ask who is next. Your toddler might decide they want to go next. Another tactic that you can use is when you ask who wants to go next? Have the other parent be all into wanting to go next. Then say, you have to wait your turn because it’s (toddler’s name) turn. This will make your toddler feel very special that it is their turn.

Additionally, this game gives them positive parent attention. You all watch and wait to see what they decide it tastes like. Feel free to even ask questions. Is it hot?

Lastly, do not force it. You might have to play the game a few times to get your toddler to want to partake. Start with foods they will sometimes eat for you and then once they are really into the game, go for harder ones. If need be, call in the reinforcements. Have grandparents over and have them play the game. If your toddler idolizes an older kid or a friend, then have them play the game too. It is amazing what some peer pressure can do.

Before you know it, they will be eating and trying all kinds of foods.

Why it works

It might seem like just a game but what you are actually doing is something that you probably do in other aspects of your parenting. With toddlers and little kids, a big part of parenting is helping them understand new experiences and the emotions that come along with it.

For instance, before we went to the dentist for the first time we read as many books as I could find about going to the dentist. We also played dentist with her stuffed animals. She got to be the dentist and check on their teeth. Beside it being a lot of pretend play fun, it helped her better prepare for the event. It wasn’t new to her.

This game is the same thing. It is the prep work to make them familiar with new foods. By playing the game yourself, you are showing her that everyone tries new foods. You are reacting in all types of ways by making funny faces. When kids try a food and aren’t too sure of the taste or texture, it is confusing when you are like see isn’t it yummy. I love broccoli. You are teaching them that the right response is whatever they feel, not they must smile and like it.

Stop “sneaking” food into their meals

First, my favorite way of adding vegetables to meals is through sauces and smoothies. I love to add carrots and spinach to smoothies. I also like to dice (small enough so my toddler can’t pick them out) peppers, carrots, and onions into pasta sauces. My newest favorite is to add pureed spinach and kale to pesto. Trader Joes actually has a pesto made with kale. It’s really good. We also make black bean dip and hummus in the food processor.

People love adding foods their toddler won’t eat in this fashion, but it won’t help you get them to eat or try the foods. Instead, you want to include them in cooking. You want them to see you add the carrot to the smoothie. Watch you add vegetables to the tomato sauce. Then they will see that the thing they love, like their smoothie or spaghetti, has these food items in it and maybe those food items aren’t so foreign and scary to try.

Start doing a no thank you bite

Similar to the taste game, the no thank you bite gets your child to try new foods one bite at a time. The more they try them the more they will like them.

When your child says they don’t like it without trying it, you follow up with “you have to try it to decide”. Have one bite and if you don’t want to eat it then just say no thank you.

While I haven’t found this to be as effective as the taste game, I know many parents who have made this work really well for them.

Monkey see, monkey do

The best way for your child to love eating healthy foods is to see you eating them. If they watch you enjoy eating vegetables, then they are so much more inclined to eat them as well. This is one of the reasons I say that having everyone eat the same thing is important. It models for them that you like the same foods that they are eating. After all, they want to be like you.

Read books about it and play it out

Toddlers learn best through being able to learn about the process through multiple means. Read as many books as possible about trying new foods. My favorite is a Charlie and Lola book I will never not ever eat a tomato. Whenever we eat seaweed, we say it is mermaid foods.

We also try to play trying new foods in pretend play. For instance, when we play kitchen and restaurant I always ask my toddler to make me a new food because I want to try it. She then brings me some imaginary food and I say oh you brought me a carrot I then make a lot of funny faces and have her also try the imaginary food.

Join a farm share

We joined a farm share where you pick up and you can also pick your own vegetables. My toddler loves helping with this. She likes to count how many carrots we put in the basket. She loves to pick berries and tomatoes. But the absolute best part of it all is that she is willing to try the food she picks. She wouldn’t eat a berry for me at home, but she gobbles them off the bush. It also allows her to see where food is actually from (the ground and not a store).

Our farm also always has flowers to pick and we bring them home and put them in a vase so we can have fresh flowers every week. My toddler absolutely loves it.

Keep at it and keep your emotions in check

The only way to make progress is to be consistent. It takes years of trying some foods for them to like it. However, I promise that if they keep trying these foods, then they will like them.

Remember to not get frustrated and keep your emotions in check. The more you react, the more they will fight. If you get mad when they won’t try a food, then they are now associating the whole process of eating a new food with it being scary. Try to remain neutral and not react.

Pursue healthy eating Today

Eating healthy is a skill that you build over a lifetime. I am still finding new ways to eat healthier. Remove the pressure and start getting your little one to enjoy new foods by turning it into a game.

The more fun you make it, the more fun they will have. By avoiding questions such as “do you like it?”, you change the goal of trying new foods. Validate all of the weird tastes and textures they experience and they will start to enjoy trying new foods.

If you found this post helpful, please share it on Pinterest or Facebook


Sharing is caring!

The Best Board Games For a 5-Year-Old - Pursue Today

Tuesday 15th of March 2022

[…] progress. All of my tips, one of which is this game, are all in my post about how to get your picky toddler to eat but applies to kids 5 and […]

Your Guide to the Controlling Emotional Toddler

Thursday 2nd of January 2020

[…] have written a whole post on this since it was such a battle in our house. The first things I had to learn was that by always asking […]

As a Mom, I Used to Hate this Phrase, But Don’t Anymore -

Wednesday 9th of October 2019

[…] one is that everyone takes a turn talking about their day. If you have some picky toddler eaters, definitely add this game to your nightly dinner to get them to get some new […]

Baby Registry Lessons to Save you Money - Pursue Today

Thursday 19th of September 2019

[…] We went super cheap on our high chair with our first baby and it was such a pain to clean. This led us to not want to feed baby in the high chair. The result was that she didn’t get introduced to or try as many foods as a baby/toddler. We relied a lot on packets and then later on had a very picky toddler. We then had to work hard to get our toddler to try new foods. […]

This page may contain affiliate links.

Sharing is Caring

Help spread the word. You're awesome for doing it!