I used to fill Easter eggs with candy because I thought that’s just what you did. But every year, my kids would get hyped up on sugar, half the candy would sit forgotten in a bowl, and I’d find melted chocolate disasters in couch cushions weeks later. So last year, I decided to break the cycle—no candy, no cheap junk that gets tossed in five minutes. Instead, I looked for surprises that were actually fun, exciting, and worth keeping.
What I discovered changed everything about our Easter egg hunt. These ideas made the experience more creative, more exciting, and way more memorable for my kids. Some of them I wish I had thought of years ago—seriously, why did no one tell me about these before?! If you’re planning your Easter egg hunt this month, do yourself a favor: skip the candy and try these instead. Your kids will be just as excited (if not more), and you won’t have to deal with sugar crashes or forgotten sweets.
1. Puzzle Pieces (That Form a Secret Message!)
Buy a small puzzle, put it together and write with sharpie a secret message and split the pieces into different eggs. Once the kids find all the pieces, they’ll have to work together to complete the picture—or even uncover a secret message like “Check under the couch for a surprise!”
2. Mini Spy Gadgets
Invisible ink pens, tiny magnifying glasses, or decoder rings instantly turn Easter into a secret agent mission. My kids spent hours writing hidden messages and cracking codes!
3. Glow-in-the-Dark Stickers for a Nighttime Egg Hunt
This was a total game-changer for us. Instead of a regular morning egg hunt, we waited until dusk, filled eggs with glow stickers, and turned our backyard into a magical glowing adventure.
4. Bath Bombs That Hatch Surprise Toys
Mini bath bombs with a hidden toy inside are next-level exciting. When kids drop them in water, they’ll fizz and reveal a tiny prize—it’s like a second surprise!
5. Tiny Parachute Toys
These were my biggest regret—I wish I had discovered them years ago! Toss them in the air and watch them drift down slowly; kids will do this over and over again.
6. Mini Watercolor Paint Sets
Find those tiny watercolor palettes that fit perfectly in an egg. Add a mini paintbrush, and you’ve got an instant DIY art kit.
or roll up the pages from these pre-set water coloring pages into eggs!
7. Mystery Keys
Hide different small keys in eggs and tell your kids they unlock a special surprise hidden somewhere in the house. You could use a locked box, a toy chest, or even a secret candy stash (if you still want a little treat involved).
8. Letter Beads for Personalized Bracelets
Each egg contains beads that spell out a child’s name or favorite word. After the hunt, they can string them together and make their own DIY bracelet or keychain.
9. Joke Scrolls (The Good Kind!)
Write actually funny kid jokes (not the groan-worthy ones from Christmas crackers) and roll them into tiny scrolls. Hearing kids crack up reading them is the best part.
10. Tiny Gliders
Those foam airplane gliders that actually fly? Instant hit. Hide different colors and let kids race them after the egg hunt.
11. Slime or Play Dough Kits
Mini containers of pre-made slime or play dough never disappoint. Just make sure to use leak-proof eggs to avoid a mess!
12. Magic Grow Capsules
Drop them in warm water, and they transform into foam dinosaurs, animals, or sea creatures. It’s ridiculously entertaining to watch them expand.
13. Foreign Coins or Lucky Pennies
Find interesting coins from different countries or a gold-colored dollar coin. It turns Easter into a real treasure hunt!
14. Pull-Back Cars
My kids were obsessed with these tiny race cars. Hide different ones in eggs, and after the hunt, set up a race track for extra fun.
15. Riddle Hunt Clues
Instead of just finding eggs, have each one contain a clue leading to a bigger hidden prize. This makes Easter morning feel like a real-life treasure hunt.
16. Target Gift Cards (Even $1 Ones!)
Even a small $1 or $2 gift card feels so special to kids. They’ll love picking out their own little toy later.
17. Tiny Fidget Toys
Mini pop-its, stretchy pea pods, or squishies are instant winners. Perfect for kids who love something to keep their hands busy.
18. Hair Clips or Bow Ties
These were such a cute surprise for my kids. Fill eggs with mini claw clips, bows, or tiny ties to dress up after the hunt.
19. Moon Sand
A small bag of kinetic sand was way better than slime for us. No sticky mess, but tons of sensory fun.
20. Easter Egg Trophies
Fill an egg with mini gold trophies labeled “Egg Hunt Champion”. My kids displayed them proudly on their shelves all year.
21. Lip Balm or Mini Nail Polish
My daughter freaked out when she found mini lip balms in her eggs. Perfect for little ones who love playing dress-up.
22. Monopoly Money for a Post-Hunt Game
Give them pretend cash, and after the hunt, let them use it to “buy” a bigger prize from a parent-run Easter store.
23. Finger Puppets
Put one in each egg and let the kids act out a puppet show when they’re done. Bonus points if they make up a story on the spot!
24. Wildflower Seeds
Each egg holds a different type of flower seed. Kids get to plant their own Easter garden and watch it grow.
25. DIY Shrinky Dinks
Pre-cut shrinky dink plastic fits perfectly in an egg. Kids decorate, bake, and wear their own custom charm.
26. Tiny Origami Kits
Pre-folded squares and simple instructions turn eggs into mini DIY origami kits. My kids loved learning new folding tricks.
27. Scratch-Off Coupons for Fun Activities
Make homemade coupons like “Stay up 30 minutes late” or “Extra bedtime story.” Kids hoard these like gold.
28. Song Lyrics Guessing Game
Print lines from popular songs and let kids guess the title. This hilarious game is even fun for adults to join in.
29. Secret Code Messages
Write secret messages in mirror writing or with invisible ink pens. Kids love decoding them!
30. Mini Flashlights
Perfect for nighttime adventures or reading under the covers. They’ll love playing with them long after Easter is over.
31. Sticker Sheets
Instead of just one sticker, put a full sheet inside the eggs. Let them collect all the designs by the end of the hunt!
32. DIY Glow-in-the-Dark Stars
Put a few per egg, and let kids stick them on their ceiling to create their own starry sky.
33. Tiny Books (Yes, They Exist!)
Miniature fairy tale books or joke books make eggs feel extra magical.
34. Harmonica or Whistle
Yes, it’s loud, but kids will love it (and parents can set limits later).
35. Mini Compass
If you have little explorers, this is a must-have. They’ll be obsessed with finding their way around the yard.
36. Miniature Nerf Darts
If your kids already have Nerf blasters, they will freak out finding extra darts in their eggs.
37. Good Luck Charms
Tiny worry stones, lucky pennies, or good luck charms make for meaningful egg fillers.
38. Balloon Animal Kits
Each egg contains a balloon, and at the end, parents make balloon animals for everyone!
39. Mini Magic Tricks
Include simple props for easy magic tricks. Kids will love performing their own Easter magic show!
40. Reusable Water Balloons
These soft, refillable water balloons turn into the ultimate backyard battle.
41. Play Foam
A little tub of play foam is a mess-free alternative to slime or dough.
42. Temporary Tattoos
Look for metallic or glow-in-the-dark tattoos for an extra cool surprise.
43. Tiny Disguises
Fake mustaches, clown noses, or tiny superhero masks will crack your kids up.
44. DIY Raft Kits
Popsicle sticks, glue dots, and mini flags let kids build and race their own mini rafts.
45. Magic Color-Changing Markers
Put one marker per egg and let kids discover the color-changing magic!
46. LEGO Mini Figures
Mix up different characters so kids get a full set after the hunt.
47. Easter-Themed Rubber Ducks
My toddler loved finding cute bunny and chick rubber ducks.
48. Fun-Shaped Erasers
Tiny taco erasers? Mini sneaker erasers? Coolest school supplies ever.
49. Collectible Card Game Packs
Pokémon, baseball, or trading cards are easy, fun, and timeless.
50. Target Coins for a Nerf Gun or Sling Shot Game
Use plastic coins that kids can redeem later for a family Nerf or slingshot battle!
The Secret to the Best Easter Egg Hunt Ever
I’ll never go back to candy-filled eggs again. The joy, excitement, and creativity that came from these non-candy fillers completely transformed our Easter morning. No sugar crashes, no stale jellybeans getting tossed out a month later—just pure fun that lasted long after the egg hunt was over.
If you’re tired of the same old Easter routine, this is your sign to try something new. Your kids will love it, and you might just start a new family tradition. So go ahead—fill those eggs with something amazing this year. You’ll be glad you did!
We’re two sisters with a passion for wearable style and interior design mixed in with some self-care and family tips. Our blog is dedicated to helping you find your unique fashion formula, both in your wardrobe and your living space. Follow us for style tips, home décor inspiration, self care ideas, family advice that help you create changes that reflect who you are.